Just looking at the 35 Yankees losses to date this season:
In 6 of the 35, the Yankees scored 5+ runs.
In 10 of the 35, the Yankees scored 4+ runs.
In 19 of the 35, the Yankees scored 3+ runs.
In 16 of the 35, the Yankees have scored 2 runs or less.
In 12 of the 35 losses, the Yankees have allowed 5 runs or less.
In 5 of the 35 losses, the Yankees have allowed 4 runs or less.
In 4 of the 35 losses, the Yankees have allowed 3 runs or less.
Let us assume that the Yankees should have won those 6 games where they scored 5+ runs and also should have won those 4 games where they allowed 3 runs or less. That would make the Yankees record to date 47-25 instead of the actual 37-35. (That 47-25 sure looks like what most of us expected them to have at this point in the season!)
What were the scores of these 10 losses? Here’s the list:
Lost to the Angels 3-1
Lost to Kansas City 3-1
Lost to Milwaukee 2-1
Lost to Toronto 2-0
Lost to Tampa Bay 11-8
Lost to Toronto 8-6
Lost to Baltimore 7-6
Lost to Seattle 7-6
Lost to Baltimore 12-5
Lost to Boston 8-5
The games that stand out the most to me here are:
Lost to Kansas City 3-1
Lost to Milwaukee 2-1
Lost to Tampa Bay 11-8
Lost to Toronto 8-6
Lost to Baltimore 7-6
Lost to Seattle 7-6
Lost to Boston 8-5
The Toronto 2-0 loss was a good game by Halladay, the Angels are a great team and the 12-5 loss to the O’s was a game where Wright was pitching BP (and I was there). This is why I can give a pass on these three.
The 3-1 loss to KC was a game where the Unit pitched well but the team just did not show up to play – and Torre ripped them for it.
The 2-1 loss to the Brewers was a game where Pavano pitched well, but the bats were flat. (The Yankees got only 4 hits that night.)
The 11-8 loss to Tampa Bay was the game where Henn made his first start. Not much you can do there.
The 8-6 loss to the Blue Jays was a game where Pavano got pounded and Stanton did a bad job out of the pen.
The 7-6 loss to the O’s was a game were Sturtze and Gordon blew the game – allowing 5 runs in the 7th.
The 7-6 loss to Seattle was one of the ugly ones of the season to date – Sturtze, Gordon, Posada, Womack and Giambi should all have bad memories from that one.
The 8-5 loss to the Bosox was the game where the fan took a swipe at Sheffield. The game was tied, 5-5, and then Gordon got banged around for 3 runs in the 8th to blow it.
OK, so, knowing all this, maybe we should throw out these games:
Lost to Kansas City 3-1
Lost to Milwaukee 2-1
Lost to Tampa Bay 11-8
And, just look at these:
Lost to Toronto 8-6
Lost to Baltimore 7-6
Lost to Seattle 7-6
Lost to Boston 8-5
When you look at these four games, the thing that pops out the most is “Tom Gordon.”
Now, this is not meant to rip Tom Gordon – because he also, to date, has helped towards 14 of the Yankees 37 wins.
But, what it does tell me is that the Yankees problem this year, so far, has been the bullpen. All four of these games were losses because of the pen:
Lost to Toronto 8-6
Lost to Baltimore 7-6
Lost to Seattle 7-6
Lost to Boston 8-5
If you take those games and make them wins, then the Yankees are 41-31, instead of 37-35, and then they would be just 1 game out of 1st at this moment.
So, if the Yankees are looking for help on the trade-front, maybe they should focus on getting some pen help and replace guys like Quantrill and Stanton who are just taking up space?
