Also, Pelfrey pitched lights out in High-A ball, but has struggled a bit in AA and needs to develop his offspeed pitches before he’ll be major league ready.

Look at their minor league numbers. There is a reason Milledge came with a lot more hype, his numbers are a lot better. That being said they both have a lot to prove and look to have a lot of potential.

More like how they’re holding on Bannister, Wright, Heilman & Reyes…

Yeah, like they held on to Kazmir.

Actually, I think the Mets’ll hold on to Lastings.

More likely, raf, Omar will be tempted to trade him for Dontrelle (along with Pelfrey…who most Mets fans (and the gullible press around here)think can pitch in the major leagues after two months of pitching less-than-successfully in High-A ball). One thing you’ve got to give the Mets and some other organizations — they’re smart enough to actually showcase the prospects they’re not that sure of so they can trade them and at least get some value for them. Unlike the Yankees, who would rather give PT to the likes of Erickson and Long. Omar’s happy Milledge has made a splash this weekend. Means the Marlins will be salivating. There’s always another Mike Cameron or Xavier Nady to play RF in Shea Stadium

I suppose it just bugs me how these two are treated so differently. People still seem to think that Melky is “suspect,” and that he won’t be around when the Yankees trade for someone. Lastings, who’s proved nothing yet, already has his spot in the HOF, if you’re to believe the hacks who write in this town.
===================
Lastings will get run out of town. Watch.

Very few of the baseball columnists and even fewer of the beat reporters have any clue about minor league prospects (I can only think of 1 NY writer who has even made the effort to watch a NY farm team…Andrew Marchand who admitted it was the first time for him when he recently went to see Milledge play in Binghamton to get some background on the kid for a column). For the most part, they rely on the “expert” opinion of either ML scouts from rival teams (yeah, like you’d get an unbiased opinion about a Yankees prospect from a Red Sox employee) or the BA-types (who are unwilling to admit that they are not objective and are HUGE fans of certain teams whether it’s the Red Sox, the Dodgers, or the Kansas City Royals).

All I know is I want one of those “Got Melky?” shirts. I’m loving this kid and I’m so thrilled he’s playing a big role on the team this year. It’s nice to see some young faces out there doing well.

The whole Melky/Lastings thing shows the hypocrisy of the New York media. When Melky got called up, everyone was against it, said he couldn’t play here, said he wasn’t a real prospect, said he was a fourth outfielder. And all because he wasn’t highly ranked by places like “BA” and because he had a bad six-game stint at TWENTY years old. But Lastings, who was a high draft pick and who was slobbered over by “BA” and whose name they had heard of, arrived like a God or a King. People in the press were already saying, without him having a single big-league hit, that he was the rightfielder/leftfielder of the future for the Mets.

People in the press — even guys like Sherman and Madden, who write about it so much — don’t know a lot about guys in the minors. So unless you’re a high draft pick or unless they’ve heard your name a few times, they attack you. Everyone goes on and on about the skills of Lastings, but Melky is the same age and could end up being the better player. He certainly has looked more comfortable than Lastings (who, though he has A LOT of attitude, looks like a good player).

I suppose it just bugs me how these two are treated so differently. People still seem to think that Melky is “suspect,” and that he won’t be around when the Yankees trade for someone. Lastings, who’s proved nothing yet, already has his spot in the HOF, if you’re to believe the hacks who write in this town.