I’m a big Andy Pettitte fan. I thought the Yankees should have never let him get away.
But, that said, when I now look at the worst games started by Yankees pitchers in the post-season, of all-time, I can make a case that Andy Pettitte has “authored” 6 of the 12 worst post-season “Games Started” flops in Yankees history. See the following bad outings that Pettitte has made while with New York:
Let’s hope that tonight doesn’t give Andy seven in the top twelve.