Who’s Really Driving Them In?
One of the great things that you can find at BaseballMusings.com is RBI Percentages. In my “perfect world,” instead of seeing “RBI” totals in the graphics that they show on T.V., when a batter steps to the plate, they would show “RBI%” instead. After all, what’s more valuable to a team – a batter who drives in 100 runs and leaves 300 men on base or a batter who drives in 80 runs and leaves 50 men on base?
To date, via BaseballMusings.com, here are the Yankees leaders in RBI% -
Player Runners RBI HR RBI% Johnny Damon 254 59 12 18.5 Xavier Nady 342 84 22 18.1 Brett Gardner 50 9 0 18.0 Bobby Abreu 398 84 15 17.3 Derek Jeter 351 66 9 16.2 Hideki Matsui 221 44 9 15.8 Jason Giambi 382 87 28 15.5 Alex Rodriguez 393 91 32 15.0 Wilson Betemit 117 21 5 13.7 Jorge Posada 141 22 3 13.5 Robinson Cano 363 61 13 13.2 Chad Moeller 58 8 1 12.1 Ivan Rodriguez 243 35 7 11.5 Richie Sexson 230 36 12 10.4 Melky Cabrera 296 36 8 9.5 Shelly Duncan 53 6 1 9.4 Jose Molina 161 15 2 8.1 Morgan Ensberg 60 4 1 5.0
The numbers above for Nady, I-Rod, and Sexson also reflect what they did prior to joining the Yankees.
Over the last three seasons, guys like Miguel Cabrera, Magglio Ordonez, Justin Morneau, Vladimir Guerrero, Lance Berkman, Ryan Howard, David Wright, David Ortiz and Albert Pujols have pretty much been around 18% to 20% in terms of their RBI%. So, for me, this says that your really good RBI guys should be at 18% or over.
Note how many here, on the Yankees list, are at 18% or higher. Tells you something, huh?





After all, what’s more valuable to a team – a batter who drives in 100 runs and leaves 300 men on base or a batter who drives in 80 runs and leaves 50 men on base?
-
All else being equal, the guy who drives in 100 runs.
Really?
So, the guy who drives in 100 out of 400 is more valuable than the guy who drives in 80 of of 130?
Not to me…
Well, if we’re still keeping score by the number of runs, then yes. If guy number two was consistently driving in 8/13, I’d put him in the slot of the other guy and presumably he’d be more valuable, but if he’s unable to play full time or whatever, then the guy getting me more runs is getting me more runs.
That was a damn ugly sentence.
[...] 172 PA). And, it’s because Robinson Cano, who usually bats 6th or 7th in the Yankees line-up, just doesn’t drive in runners – [...]