Albert has put up some sick numbers and is a higher impact player. However, ARod is in great shape and may last long enough to see all the records fall. I’d rather have ARod ONLY because the records are already falling, and it’s fun to watch.

Hell… why can’t we have both?

I would have traded Joe DiMaggio for Ted Williams too.

I would take Pujols because he’s a better hitter. I’d take the positional hit.

Pujols also is an outstanding fielder at his position; A-rod is only average at 3rd.

Pujols is also 5 years younger. Allegedly.

I’ll let others debate the “obvious” difference in clutch hitting.