Prospect Poop
I’ve gotten a few e-mails from folks regarding Keith Law’s “Ranking the top prospects” feature at ESPN.com today.
It seems that Yankees prospects Austin Jackson (#46), Jesus Montero (#83) and Andrew Brackman (#95) made the cut.
Here’s the deal. The Yankees have a few prospects in their farm system. Most teams do. In the big picture, the Yankees probably have about as many quality prospects in their system as one-third of the teams in baseball, thereabouts. And, there are some teams who have more blue-chip prospects than the Yankees. And, there are some teams who have less top prospects than the Yankees. But, it’s not like some teams are head-and-shoulders above the Yankees in terms of having Grade-A prospects. And, it’s not like the Yankees have a gaggle of hot prospects that is twice the size of some other teams.
I know that some Yankees fanboys and/or bloggers like to carry on about the prospects in the Yankees system, etc., as if Yankees prospects walk on water and they are better than a regular slice of heaven. But, that’s all hyperbole. And, anyone who buys into that, and who starts to think that the Yankees front office is so much better at seeding a farm system than most other baseball teams, is looking through rose-colored glasses.
After all, did the Yankees not have to spend a half-billion dollars this off-season to fill big league needs at first base and two starting pitcher slots?
None of those three needs came out of the thin air. Anyone could have told you three years ago that the Yankees would have a need at first base in 2009. And, most could have guessed, back in 2006, that New York’s starting rotation might have needs for this season. Yet, when the time came to address those needs, the farm system had nothing for the Yankees to call upon – hence the spending spree this winter.
So, if the Yankees farm system is so good, why could it not produce two starting pitchers and a first baseman?
Further, at the end of 2007, the Yankees were left without a catcher. Having no one in the minors, they overpaid to keep Jorge Posada in town. Everyone knew Posada’s age and when his contract was going to end. It did not sneak up on anyone. Yet, again, the Yankees farm system was no help there.
Sure, I know what’s coming now…the cries of “Just wait! There’s guys in the low minors now who will be helping the Yankees in 2015!”
Yeah, and, the check is in the mail, I don’t think you look fat, it happens to a lot of guys, and this will only hurt for a second…






