FYI – For the folks who weren’t around when Steve ran P46, this is what I’m talking about:

http://waswatching.com/2007/12/03/did-project-p46-help/

Corey wrote:

so lets say the playoffs started today, and the yanks were in it, who do u lineup to pitch game 3? Pettitte for me

If the playoffs started today, I’d go CC-Joba-Burnett-Andy.

I love Andy, always have and always will. I was part of Steve’s P46 and I feel like I had something to do with his coming back (no matter how ridiculous that might sound). But he was horrid in 2nd half of last year and he’s been horrid in his last 5 starts and I’m growing a bit concerned about Pettitte overall. He’s still got a few good games left in him, I’m sure, but more often than not, I don’t think he’s going to be a particularly effective starter.

I’m a big believe in having a big game pitcher for game 3, as its a pivotal game more often than not

so lets say the playoffs started today, and the yanks were in it, who do u lineup to pitch game 3? Pettitte for me

Corey wrote:

still, big game, who aside from CC would you prefer pitching it over Pettitte?

Whoever our 2nd best pitcher is. By the end of the season, it wouldn’t surprise me if that’s Joba.

pettitte’s been sayin this might not be his ast season more recently

I’m assuming that Pettitte meant it when he hinted/said that this would be his last season.

I’m also assuming that if the Yanks somehow win it all, he’ll definitely retire.

still, big game, who aside from CC would you prefer pitching it over Pettitte?

as long as Pettitte is able, I keep him on the team
———-
FWIW, Pettitte isn’t exactly pitching great of late (5.34 ERA in his last 5 starts / 2.53 ERA in his first 3 starts).