The goal here is to identify baseball’s all-time best “all-around” non-pitchers with respect to batting, running and fielding. To that end, I used the following career cut-offs on this sort: 300+ Batting Runs, 75+ Fielding Runs and 30+ Runs from Base Running. And, here is the final result:
| Rk |
Player |
WAR/pos |
Rbat |
Rfield |
Rbaser |
From |
To |
Age |
G |
|
R |
H |
|
|
HR |
RBI |
BB |
SB |
BA |
OBP |
SLG |
| 1 |
Barry Bonds |
158.1 |
1128 |
175 |
44 |
1986 |
2007 |
21-42 |
2986 |
|
2227 |
2935 |
|
|
762 |
1996 |
2558 |
514 |
.298 |
.444 |
.607 |
| 2 |
Willie Mays |
150.8 |
808 |
183 |
75 |
1951 |
1973 |
20-42 |
2992 |
|
2062 |
3283 |
|
|
660 |
1903 |
1464 |
338 |
.302 |
.384 |
.557 |
| 3 |
Hank Aaron |
137.3 |
876 |
98 |
42 |
1954 |
1976 |
20-42 |
3298 |
|
2174 |
3771 |
|
|
755 |
2297 |
1402 |
240 |
.305 |
.374 |
.555 |
| 4 |
Honus Wagner |
110.0 |
532 |
75 |
31 |
1901 |
1917 |
27-43 |
2298 |
|
1414 |
2766 |
|
|
78 |
1375 |
836 |
601 |
.325 |
.392 |
.462 |
| 5 |
Al Kaline |
87.4 |
473 |
153 |
38 |
1953 |
1974 |
18-39 |
2834 |
|
1622 |
3007 |
|
|
399 |
1583 |
1277 |
137 |
.297 |
.376 |
.480 |
| 6 |
Larry Walker |
69.7 |
420 |
95 |
39 |
1989 |
2005 |
22-38 |
1988 |
|
1355 |
2160 |
|
|
383 |
1311 |
913 |
230 |
.313 |
.400 |
.565 |
.
Without seeing the result, I could have guessed at the first four here. But, I am not sure, at first blush, if I would have named Kaline without seeing the data. And, for sure, I would have been hard pressed to name Walker – but, the data supports his inclusion. As good as Walker was as a player, perhaps, in a sense, one could suggest that he is under-rated (and would have been considered an all-time elite great if he had more playing time)?
Lastly, I think that Rickey Henderson and Roberto Clemente deserve some honorable mention here. See the following:
| Player |
WAR/pos |
Rbat |
Rfield |
Rbaser |
From |
To |
Age |
G |
|
R |
H |
|
|
HR |
RBI |
BB |
SB |
BA |
OBP |
SLG |
| Rickey Henderson |
106.8 |
556 |
66 |
144 |
1979 |
2003 |
20-44 |
3081 |
|
2295 |
3055 |
|
|
297 |
1115 |
2190 |
1406 |
.279 |
.401 |
.419 |
| Roberto Clemente |
89.8 |
377 |
204 |
21 |
1955 |
1972 |
20-37 |
2433 |
|
1416 |
3000 |
|
|
240 |
1305 |
621 |
83 |
.317 |
.359 |
.475 |
.
These two just sorta/kinda missed the cut here – so close that a good case could be made for their inclusion and expanding this group from six to eight.
Oh, and, if you want to make it a “Prime Nine” then I would throw in this guy as well:
| Player |
WAR/pos |
Rbat |
Rfield |
Rbaser |
From |
To |
Age |
G |
|
R |
H |
|
|
HR |
RBI |
BB |
SB |
BA |
OBP |
SLG |
| Jackie Robinson |
58.7 |
262 |
81 |
30 |
1947 |
1956 |
28-37 |
1382 |
|
947 |
1518 |
|
|
137 |
734 |
740 |
197 |
.311 |
.409 |
.474 |
.
And, a great case can be made, if not for the courage of Jackie, then most of the guys on the above lists would not have been able to play down the line. And, we’d probably be talking about guys like this here, below, instead (in terms of baseball’s best “all-around” players):
| Player |
WAR/pos |
Rbat |
Rfield |
Rbaser |
From |
To |
Age |
G |
|
R |
H |
|
|
HR |
RBI |
BB |
SB |
BA |
OBP |
SLG |
| Honus Wagner |
110.0 |
532 |
75 |
31 |
1901 |
1917 |
27-43 |
2298 |
|
1414 |
2766 |
|
|
78 |
1375 |
836 |
601 |
.325 |
.392 |
.462 |
| Al Kaline |
87.4 |
473 |
153 |
38 |
1953 |
1974 |
18-39 |
2834 |
|
1622 |
3007 |
|
|
399 |
1583 |
1277 |
137 |
.297 |
.376 |
.480 |
| Jeff Bagwell |
76.7 |
590 |
55 |
30 |
1991 |
2005 |
23-37 |
2150 |
|
1517 |
2314 |
|
|
449 |
1529 |
1401 |
202 |
.297 |
.408 |
.540 |
| Larry Walker |
69.7 |
420 |
95 |
39 |
1989 |
2005 |
22-38 |
1988 |
|
1355 |
2160 |
|
|
383 |
1311 |
913 |
230 |
.313 |
.400 |
.565 |
| Frankie Frisch |
68.0 |
158 |
140 |
30 |
1919 |
1937 |
20-38 |
2311 |
|
1532 |
2880 |
|
|
105 |
1244 |
728 |
419 |
.316 |
.369 |
.432 |
| Scott Rolen |
66.6 |
233 |
175 |
12 |
1996 |
2012 |
21-37 |
2038 |
|
1211 |
2077 |
|
|
316 |
1287 |
899 |
118 |
.281 |
.364 |
.490 |
| Ryne Sandberg |
64.9 |
191 |
60 |
33 |
1981 |
1997 |
21-37 |
2164 |
|
1318 |
2386 |
|
|
282 |
1061 |
761 |
344 |
.285 |
.344 |
.452 |
| Goose Goslin |
61.0 |
364 |
50 |
12 |
1921 |
1938 |
20-37 |
2287 |
|
1483 |
2735 |
|
|
248 |
1609 |
949 |
176 |
.316 |
.387 |
.500 |
| Ken Boyer |
58.7 |
185 |
74 |
15 |
1955 |
1969 |
24-38 |
2034 |
|
1104 |
2143 |
|
|
282 |
1141 |
713 |
105 |
.287 |
.349 |
.462 |
| Chase Utley |
53.3 |
177 |
145 |
32 |
2003 |
2012 |
24-33 |
1192 |
|
779 |
1275 |
|
|
199 |
739 |
505 |
121 |
.288 |
.376 |
.500 |
| Sam Rice |
48.0 |
186 |
56 |
13 |
1915 |
1934 |
25-44 |
2404 |
|
1514 |
2987 |
|
|
34 |
1078 |
708 |
351 |
.322 |
.374 |
.427 |
| J.D. Drew |
42.4 |
207 |
69 |
10 |
1998 |
2011 |
22-35 |
1566 |
|
944 |
1437 |
|
|
242 |
795 |
862 |
87 |
.278 |
.384 |
.489 |
| Frank Chance |
40.9 |
199 |
51 |
28 |
1901 |
1914 |
24-37 |
1115 |
|
703 |
1134 |
|
|
18 |
547 |
519 |
378 |
.298 |
.397 |
.396 |
.
With no disrespect to any of the above, I am glad that Robinson did make it possible for guys like Bonds, Mays, Aaron, Henderson, et al, to play and the major leagues – and for us to be able to witness their greatness.